Likened
Early Alcoholics Anonymous to First Century Christianity
Albert
Scott, Chairman of the Trustees for Riverside Church in New York: In December 1937, a meeting
was held in John D. Rockefeller, Jr.’s private board room. Bill W., Dr. Bob,
and some other alcoholics from New York and Akron—together with Dr. William D. Silkworth
and Dr. Leonard Strong—met with Rockefeller’s associates Willard Richardson, A.
Leroy Chapman, Frank Amos, and Albert Scott. The meeting was chaired by Albert
Scott, chairman of the board of trustees of New York’s Riverside Church. Each
alcoholic was enjoined to tell his own personal story, after which, the
chairman Albert Scott exclaimed, “Why, this is first-century Christianity!” . .
. “What can we do to help?” [Source: Alcoholics Anonymous Comes
of Age (New York: Alcoholics
Anonymous World Services, Inc., 1957), 148]
Albert
Scott (again): John D. Rockefeller, Jr.,
arranged a dinner on February 8, 1940, at the Union Club in New York to
raise money for Alcoholics Anonymous. John D. had intended to attend; but he was
too ill to do so and sent his son Nelson Rockefeller to host the dinner.
According to a digest of the events at the dinner, Scott stated: “What they
[Bill W. and the other early AAs] had done, it seemed to me, had gone back to
the techniques of primitive Christianity, where one person told the good news
to another.” [Source:
“The Rockefeller Dinner”: http://www.barefootsworld.net/aarockdinner.html;
accessed 8/22/2014. See also: silkworth.net/gsowatch/1940/dinner_capture.pdf’]
Rockefeller
Agent Frank Amos: [In a report made in 1938 which discussed the 110
members then in the program, 70 of whom were in the Akron-Cleveland, Ohio,
area, Frank Amos stated:] “. . . [I]n many respects, their meetings have taken
on the form of the meetings described in the Gospels of the early Christians
during the first century.”
[Source: Dr. Bob and the Good
Oldtimers (New York, N.Y.:
Alcoholics Anonymous World Services, Inc., 1980), 135-36]
John D.
Rockefeller, Jr., himself: “Willard
Richardson [a close associate of John D. Rockefeller, Jr.] added his approval
to the report [prepared by Rockefeller agent Frank Amos after his thorough
investigation of early A.A. in Akron in February 1938] and immediately passed
it on to Mr. Rockefeller. . . . Rockefeller was impressed. He saw
the parallel with early Christianity and along with this he spotted a
combination of medicine and religion that appealed to all his charitable
inclinations.” [Robert Thomsen, Bill W. (New York: Harper & Row, 1975), 275]
Nelson
Rockefeller, speaking about his father, John D. Rockefeller, Jr.: Bill Wilson’s wife Lois made
the following statement in her memoirs about the dinner Nelson Rockefeller
hosted on behalf of his father (who was too ill to attend) at the Union Club in
New York on February 8, 1940, to raise money for Alcoholics Anonymous: “When
Nelson [Rockefeller] finally got up to talk, there was a great deal of
expectancy. He told how impressed his father [John D. Rockefeller, Jr.] was
with this unique movement, which resembled early Christianity.” [Source: Lois Remembers (New York: Al-Anon Family Group
Headquarters, Inc., 1987), 128-29]
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteThe claim that J.D. Rockefeller, Jr. ever believed or said AA was “First Century Christian” is wholly unsubstantiated hearsay, AA myth. No direct evidence from the Rockefellers or their associates has ever confirmed this designation.
ReplyDeleteJ.D. Rockefeller Jr. also never met with Bill Wilson (who had a checkered reputation as a Wall Street hustler); to claim otherwise is misleading.
ALL traces stem from one comment by one man (Albert L. Scott) on 2/8/1940: he said "primitive Christianity."
fwiw, the book 'Alcoholics Anonymous' (1939) is actually more 'Judeo-Hellenic' than 'Christian': closer to Philo than Paul.
More serious scholarship on Albert L. Scott (creator of "AA"?) is warranted.