Friday, August 17, 2012

Part 4: AA Big Book 1st ed Personal Stories and Christianity



That Frequently Mentions the Bible and God

(Yep! You Read That Correctly!)



A Four-Part Discussion of the Long-Overlooked Big Book Personal Stories



Part Four



Alcoholics Anonymous: The Original 1939 Edition (continued)

(Dover Publications, Inc., 2011)




By Dick B.

© 2012 Anonymous. All rights reserved







About Part One



In Part One, we discussed the A.A. General Service Conference-approved book, Experience, Strength and Hope: Stories from the First Three Editions of Alcoholics Anonymous (New York, NY: Alcoholics Anonymous World Services, Inc., 2003). It elevated to “Conference-approved” status the many personal stories from the first edition of the Big Book (1939), the second edition (1955), and the third edition (1976) that were not included in the fourth edition (2001). We pointed to the questionable explanations in Experience, Strength and Hope for the omission of so many of the first edition’s personal stories from later editions of Alcoholics Anonymous. And we covered how the discussion of God, His Son Jesus Christ, and the Bible in the personal stories in the first edition provided a solid foundation for responding to concerns such as “You can’t talk about Jesus or the Bible in an A.A. meeting!” and “The Bible (and books such as Dick B.’s The Good Book and the Big Book: A.A.’s Roots in the Bible) are not ‘Conference-approved!’



About Part Two



In Part Two, we discussed the 2011 publication Alcoholics Anonymous:  The Original 1939 Edition: With a new Introduction by Dick B. (Mineola, NY: Dover Publications, Inc., 2011). We covered how the Introduction explains in detail the importance of the 29 personal stories in the first edition of Alcoholics Anonymous, 22 of which were left out of the second and third editions, and four more of which were left out of the fourth edition. We reviewed seven of the 29 first edition personal stories, quoting places where God, His Son Jesus Christ, the Bible, and Christianity were mentioned. We also showed how these stories fit so neatly with the real Akron A.A. “Christian fellowship” program that has been the subject of so many Dick B. books and articles. See, for example: Dick B. and Ken B., The Dick B. Christian Recovery Guide, 3rd ed. (http://www.dickb.com/Christian-Recovery-Guide-files/).



About Part Three



In Part Three, we continued our discussion of the 2011 publication Alcoholics Anonymous:  The Original 1939 Edition: With a new Introduction by Dick B. (Mineola, NY: Dover Publications, Inc., 2011). We reviewed 12 more of the 29 first edition personal stories, quoting places where God, His Son Jesus Christ, the Bible, and Christianity were mentioned.



Part Four: Direct Quotes from Personal Stories

[Using page numbers from Alcoholics Anonymous: The Original 1939 Edition (Dover)]

More First Edition Personal Stories about God, His Son Jesus Christ, and the Bible



1.      The Car Smasher, pp. 364-69:



I was shown what might be done about my drinking with the help of God.



My every need was being met as long as I accepted and acknowledged the Divine Help which was so generously given.



Their suggestion was that we simply acknowledge we had made a pretty dismal failure of our lives, that we accept as truth and act upon what we had always been taught and known, that there was a kind and merciful God, that we were His children, and that if we would let Him, He would help us.



There are, it seems to me, four steps by be taken by one who is a victim of alcoholism.



First: Have a real desire to quit.



Second: Admit you can’t. (This is the hardest.)



Third: Ask for His ever-present help.



Fourth: Accept and acknowledge this help.



2.      An Alcoholic’s Wife, pp. 378-79:



Since giving my husband’s problem to God I have found a peace and happiness. I know that when I try to take care of the problems of my husband I am a stumbling block as my husband has to take his problems to God the same as I do.



My husband and I now talk over our problems and trust in a Divine Power. We have now started to live. When we live with God we want for nothing.



3.      An Artist’s Concept, pp. 380-85:



A seed had been planted, however, and a short time afterward I met a man who has for the past five years devoted a great deal of time and energy to helping alcoholics. Looking back on that meeting, the simplicity of his talk with me is amazing. He told me very little but what I already knew, in part, but what he did have to say was bereft of all fancy spiritual phraseology—it was simple Christianity imparted with Divine Power.



The next day I met over twenty men who had achieved a mental rebirth from alcoholism.



4.      The Rolling Stone, pp. 386-90:



I went into the hospital and started to build my body up again through proper nourishment, and my mind through a different method than I had ever known of. A religious awakening was conveyed to me. . .



It has been nearly a year and a half since I have found this new life and I know as long as I do the few things that God requires me to do, I never will take another drink.



5.      Lone Endeavor, pp. 391-96:



I want to thank you from the bottom of my heart for your letters and for ‘ALCOHOLICS ANONYMOUS.’



Before the book arrived and after reading the chapters I knew that the only way to combat this curse was to ask the help of the greater Power, God. I realized it even though I was then on a binge.



I thought to myself, yes this is the only way. God is still my only chance. . . . I’m sure I have found the solution, thanks to ALCOHOLICS ANONYMOUS.



What the Phrase “Basic Text” Means



Over and over, when I was new, people—including me—were repeatedly told to read “the Big Book.” We were also told that this meant that we were to read: “The Doctor’s Opinion and the first 164 pages.” [In the fourth edition, “The Doctor’s Opinion” is found on pages xxv through xxxii. Chapter 1: “Bill’s Story” begins on page 1, immediately following the end of “The Doctor’s Opinion.” Chapter 11: “A Vision for You” ends on page 164. The next page—165 (unnumbered)—begins the “Personal Stories” section of Big Book.] To that advice was added the repeated expression that the “basic text” consisted only of the “Doctor’s Opinion” chapter and “the first164 pages.” Therefore, we were told NOT to read the personal stories. In fact, many that I met, that I knew in the Fellowship, and that I certainly counted as friends, simply tore out of their Big Book all of the pages containing the personal stories; i.e., pages 165 through 559(!). I believed they really felt that the stories were extraneous to the program and were unimportant.



Then I learned, of course, that A.A. itself had been systematically changing and eliminating personal stories each time a new edition of the Big Book was published. I now know it eliminated all but three of the personal stories that had originally been in the first edition. And then there was the story of Bill D. of Akron, “Alcoholic Anonymous Number Three.” His story was simply not included in the first edition. It was inserted in the “Pioneers of A.A.” portion of the “Personal Stories” section of the Big Book--following Dr. Bob’s personal story--beginning with the second edition (1955). Because Bill D.’s personal story was not included in “the first 164 pages,” most of us didn’t have a clue as to who A.A. Number Three was; what his story said; or the fact that his story contained, on page 191, “a golden text for the A.A. program.”



Another personal story, “He Thought He Could Drink Like A Gentleman”—which was added in the second edition and retained in the third edition--had described how Bill Wilson plainly told the author of the story, a newcomer, that the successful factor in the program was Jesus Christ! The author of the personal story stated that he had “wanted to know what this was that worked so many wonders, . . .” (Alcoholics Anonymous, 3rd ed., 216-17). He went on to say that Bill Wilson had answered his question by pointing to a picture of Gethsemane hanging over the mantel in the author’s home. Wilson had then simply said: “There it is!” (Alcoholics Anonymous, 3rd ed., 217). The solution! Yet that story was not included in the fourth edition of the Big Book. We will discuss it more in a moment.



A number of people over the years have tried to discourage others from studying the personal stories in the Big Book. They have told others that the personal stories are not part of the Big Book “basic text.” They have claimed that the phrase “basic text” refers only to a part of the Big Book; i.e., to the chapter titled “The Doctor’s Opinion,” “the first 164 pages,” and “Appendix II: Spiritual Experience.” This curious product of the “wisdom of the rooms” confounds reason. But to me, as a bewildered, brain-damaged newcomer, such statements not only seemed doctrinal, but they also seemed to make sense—at least at that early point in my sobriety.



Here are some noteworthy points concerning the meaning of the phrase “basic text” relative to the book Alcoholics Anonymous.



·         The latest (4th) hardback edition of Alcoholics Anonymous has a dust jacket whose front cover reads as follows: Alcoholics Anonymous: This is the Fourth Edition of the Big Book, the Basic Text for Alcoholics Anonymous. The point? The “Basic Text” consists of the whole book.



·         The language on the front cover of the dust jacket does not say the personal stories are not part of the “basic text.” It speaks of the entire edition!



·         The language on the front cover of the dust jacket also does not say that the “basic text” for A.A. consists only of the smallest portion of the book—an eight-page, preliminary chapter titled “The Doctor’s Opinion”; a mere 164 additional pages of text; and a two-page “Appendix II: Spiritual Experience.”—when compared to the 395-page “Personal Stories” section (pages 165 to 559).



·         The language on the front cover of the dust jacket does not say that the “Personal Stories” section is merely an “appendix” or “notes” or “footnotes.”



·         In the fourth edition, published in 2001, the numbered pages run from “v” (the first page of the “Contents” section) to “xxxii” (the last page of “The Doctor’s Opinion”), and from “1” (the first page of “Bill’s Story”) to “575” [the last page of Appendix VII, “The Twelve Concepts” (page 575)]. The title page of the fourth edition says: “Alcoholics Anonymous: The Story of How Many Thousands of Men and Women Have Recovered from Alcoholism, FOURTH EDITION.” It does not say that the “Story” consists only of the first 164 pages, but does not include the “Personal Stories” section (pages 165-559).



As the A.A. General Service Conference-approved” book Experience, Strength and Hope states in its Introduction on page ix:



The importance of these personal stories cannot be overstated.  The story section of the Big Book is far more important than most of us think.



Page 29 of the fourth edition states: “Further on, clear-cut directions are given showing how we recovered. These are followed by forty-two personal experiences.” It does not say that the book—the “basic text” for A.A-- merely contains Bill’s story, some directions for taking the Steps, and 42 stories that you need not bother to read. No!



Even in the fourth edition, the personal stories are testimonies, presumably written by those who followed directions. In fact, on page 58 of the fourth edition, the text explains the heart of what soon is to follow in the book: “Rarely have we seen a person fail who has thoroughly followed our path.” What path? The path followed by those who wrote the personal stories. It does not limit the successful ones to those who “thoroughly followed” Bill’s path. It says, “our path.” And the testimonies—the personal stories—show the results achieved by the individual writers thought to have “thoroughly followed” the path, together with newcomers who read and learned from those who had followed the path and explained exactly how they did it.



That path is plainly the path mapped out in the instructions and the actual path followed by those who supposedly thoroughly followed the map. And all this is certainly true of the purposeful personal stories of the pioneers—all but three of which were not included in the fourth edition.



Many decades after the second edition, published in 1955, began the trend of leaving out the vast majority of the 29 personal stories originally included in the first printing of the first edition, all of the personal stories omitted from the second, third, and fourth editions were finally restored to “official” status in 2003 with A.A.’s publication of Experience, Strength and Hope. Prior to that, the instructions merely represented a map devoid of specific descriptions of the path actually trod by A.A.’s pioneers as they described their efforts in their own language and from their own point of view. These testimonies by the early path-followers were the testimonies of selected “winners.” Without them, one had only suggestions, not the stories of winners!



A text is a text is a text, as Gertrude Stein can be paraphrased in her famous statement: “A rose is a rose is a rose is a rose.” She did not say, “A rose has many petals, but only a few petals constitute the rose.” Neither did A.A. say “Our text has more than 575 pages, but only 164 constitute the book.” It hardly takes a genius, a scholar, or a first-grader to reject that nonsense.



Two More Little-Known, Rarely-Mentioned, Personal Stories (Testimonials)



1.      He Thought He Could Drink Like a Gentleman. This personal story was found on pages 210-221 of the second and third editions, but was not included in the fourth edition. It has now been “restored” and is found on pages 237-47 of Experience, Strength and Hope. Pages 242-43 in Experience, Strength and Hope (pages 216-17 in the second and third editions) discuss a picture of Jesus in the Garden of Gethsemane. In particular, page 243 relates:



One evening I had gone out after dinner to take on a couple of double-headers and stayed a little later than usual, and when I came home Clarence [Clarence H. Snyder, who founded Cleveland A.A. in 1939] was sitting on the davenport with Bill W. I do not recollect the specific conversation that went on but I believe I did challenge Bill to tell me something about A.A. and I do recall one other thing: I wanted to know what this was that worked so many wonders, and hanging over the mantle was a picture of Gethsemane [The writer is clearly referring to a famous painting of Jesus in the Garden of Gethsemane. The details of Jesus’ praying in the Garden of Gethsemane—details which inspired the famous painting—can be found  in Matthew 26:36 and Mark 14:32—where Jesus told his disciples to sit while he went and prayed. The writer goes on to say:] and Bill pointed to it and said, “There it is.”



2.      Alcoholics Anonymous Number Three: “Pioneer member of Akron’s Group No. 1, the first A.A. group in the world. He kept the faith; therefore, he and countless others found a new life.” Page 191 of the fourth edition states:



We were eating lunch, and I was listening and trying to find out why they had this release that they seemed to have. Bill [Wilson] looked across at my wife and said to her, “Henrietta, the Lord has been so wonderful to me, curing me of this terrible disease, that I just want to keep talking about it and telling people.”



I thought, I think I have the answer. Bill was very, very grateful that he had been released from this terrible thing and he had given God the credit for having done it, and he’s so grateful about it he wants to tell other people about it.



That sentence, “The Lord has been so wonderful to me, curing me of this terrible disease, that I just want to keep telling people about it” has been a sort of a golden text for the A.A. program and for me.



[Note that, on the same occasion, Bill W. and Bill D.—A.A. Number Three—both tied their release from alcoholism to “the Lord.” Bill W. said that he had been “cured” by “the Lord.” And Dotson implied it in his comment that Bill W.’s statement was “a sort of a golden text for the A.A. program and for me.”



Read the Stories, and Find the Heavenly Father, “the Lord,” the Bible, and the “Cure”



Several things happened as people began to alter the Big Book in the second and following edition in order to eliminate things Bill W. or later “trusted” servants personally disliked and/or otherwise decided should be changed.



First, the vast majority of the personal stories included in the first edition were eliminated--personal stories which talked about the original A.A. program, and about the importance of God, His Son Jesus Christ, the Bible, and cure in that program.



Second, confusing synonyms were inserted that left readers in doubt as to what the intended meaning was. An example is the substitution of the phrase “spiritual awakening” for Wilson’s famous “spiritual experience.” The lengthy discussion of the supposed justification for the change presented in “Appendix II: Spiritual Experience” (in printings 2-16 of the first edition, and in the second, third, and fourth editions) takes two entire pages. The appendix moves from experience to awakening to awareness to personality change. And I can’t tell you how many people have stated in meetings that they have had many “experiences” or “awakenings,” and that those “experiences” or “awakenings” were of the “educational” variety. But they have said it with no idea of the origin of that solution spelled out in the Big Book and identified as the miracle of having the Creator enter into the heart of members.



Third, a concept was invented that denigrated a major portion of the supposedly “offensive” material. For example, at one point, A.A. itself published a “Big Book” which did not include any personal stories at all (other than Bill’s). And when their General Manager came to Maui, I asked him why and pointed out that the original intent of the Big Book was to have it consist only of stories. He replied in front of the audience, “You’re right.” And before long, the hybrid Big Book, sans stories, just vanished from the scene.



There are other ways that extraneous or corrupting ideas have sometimes been introduced. But let’s just take the ones that can clearly be demonstrated.



If the suffering alcoholic and his mentors do not see, in their chosen portion of an edition, the source or meaning of words and phrases such as “Heavenly Father,” “the Lord,” “the Bible, and “Cure;” and if the deletions are sometimes accompanied by apologetic explanations in their place; the readers and the leaders are left with some “higher power” or “Power,” a god or “something;” or “God as we understood Him,” when the program itself originally referred only to God or to His Son Jesus Christ.



·         Heavenly Father. If one relegates Dr. Bob’s personal story to the ignored or torn-out “Personal Stories” section later in the Big Book, one will miss the reference on page 181 by Dr. Bob that says: “Your Heavenly Father will never let you down!” In fact, the newly-published title by Hazelden, The Book That Started It All—which contains very-high-quality scans of the “printer’s manuscript” of Alcoholics Anonymous-- shows plainly the vain, last-minute attempt to substitute the word “Faith” for “Heavenly Father” in Dr. Bob’s personal story—a change that clearly was rejected. Yet compare Dr. Bob’s last major address where he repeatedly and consistently refers to “Heavenly Father.” See The Co-Founders of Alcoholics Anonymous: Biographical Sketches Their Last Major Talks (Pamphlet P-53), p. 15—“our Heavenly Father;” p. 19—“our Heavenly Father,” “My Father in heaven,” and “our Heavenly Father;” and p. 20—“our Heavenly Father.”  In fact, when I heard Dr. Bob’s son speak at the A.A. International Convention in San Diego, he repeatedly used the phrase “Heavenly Father.”
 

·         The Lord. If one relegates A.A. Number Three’s personal story to the ignored or torn out “Personal Stories” section, one will miss the two references on page 191 by Bill W. and Bill D. (AA Number Three) which state “The Lord has been so wonderful to me curing me.” Interestingly, the other place where the complete statement about “the Lord” and “cure” is quoted is in DR. BOB and the Good Oldtimers, at page 83.



Yet if one makes plain that Bill W. considered Jesus to be the solution--as found on pages 216-17 of a personal story included in the second and third editions, but not included in the fourth edition; and if Bill W. and Bill D. ascribe their cure to “the Lord” named on page 191, the meaning of the phrase “the Lord” becomes clear. Then add in Bill W.’s references to the “Great Physician” (Jesus Christ) in his autobiography, and Dr. Silkworth’s advice to Bill W. that the “Great Physician” could cure him of his alcoholism; and one begins to see how much Jesus Christ has been eliminated from the minds of all too many AAs who want to know where their ideas came from.



·         The Bible. If one eliminates all the personal stories where, as quoted above, the Bible is clearly mentioned, one is left with unattributed, undefined, floating quotes from and allusions to the Bible such as “Thy will be done;” “Faith without works is dead,” “Love thy neighbor as thyself,” “Creator,” “Maker,” “Father of lights.” And the befuddled newcomer hasn’t a clue where these words came from or to whom they refer. That newcomer may never have read the Bible or even heard the phrases—let alone understood that they were the guides for early AAs. But the personal stories in the first edition clearly tell the reader how important reliance on God, looking to His Son Jesus Christ, and reading the Bible were to complete recoveries in the early A.A. Akron “Christian fellowship.”



·         Cured. Then there’s that blinking warning word: “Cure.” A word timid AAs are quick to discard or doubt. And, ignoring his own statement and that of Bill Dotson that the Lord had cured them, Bill directly contradicted his stated faith and belief. Inconsistently, he wrote on page 85 of the Fourth Edition: “We are not cured of alcoholism.”



Bill W.’s “We are not cured of alcoholism” statement on page 85 of the fourth edition—(note that the statement is in “the first 164 pages”)--has given rise to endless controversies in the rooms over whether AAs are “in recovery,” “recovering,” or “recovered.” Seldom is the word “cured” even mentioned. It is almost regarded as anathema! Consider this: When was the last time you heard people talking about the other reference to “cure” in “the first 164 pages”: “. . . [H]is more serious ailments were being rapidly cured.” [page 135 (in “The Family Afterward” chapter)]. And see DR. BOB and the Good Oldtimers, where page 129 states “Dr. Howard S. . . . had been cured by Smith and his friends’ activities and the Christian technique prescribed.” What does that mean? It means what it says: Dr. Howard S. was cured by Dr. Bob and the activities and the “Christian technique” the good doctor and his friends “prescribed.”



If one ignores the “activities” of Dr. Bob and his friends, and ignores the “Christian technique prescribed,” then one is also ignoring the proven potential of the early Akron A.A. “Christian fellowship.”



Find the Stories and You May Just Find the Facts



Try these experiments:



·         Tell people in a meeting or a treatment program that the Big Book declares that there is a cure for alcoholism! Shock them with your statement that the “truth” stated on page 33 of the fourth edition of the Big Book—“Once an alcoholic, always an alcoholic.” simply does not apply to those cured of alcoholism by “Divine Aid”—by the power of God. Tell them again that “Once an alcoholic, always an alcoholic.” does not apply to those cured of alcoholism by the power of God. Tell the listeners, “Once an alcoholic has been cured; once an alcoholic has been delivered by the power of God; once an alcoholic has gained immunity from temptation; once an alcoholic has ‘thoroughly followed the path,’ that alcoholic has seen the problem miraculously removed!



Howls of protest may accompany every word thereafter. The reason?  Most of the howlers don’t know that all three of the first AAs said explicitly that they had been cured of alcoholism—this after each had turned to God for help and been healed.



Thus the quoted remarks of Bill W. and A.A. Number 3, on page 191—that the Lord had cured—are either unknown, claimed to be erroneous, or falling on the ears of those who don’t believe what Dr. William D. Silkworth expressly told Bill and other patients: The “Great Physician” (Jesus Christ) can cure you of your alcoholism. The protesters clearly either don’t know, or else dispute, the fact that Dr. Silkworth made a statement (before the Rockefellers, AAs, and others) that he had treated alcoholics who had been “permanently cured.”



·         Tell people in a meeting or a treatment program that, by turning to God, you have had a miraculous healing of your alcoholism.



Howls of protest may arise in your very presence to the effect that your claim is “a violation of the Traditions” because A.A. is “spiritual, not religious;” or that you have just offended someone who is an atheist, an agnostic, a Hindu, or a Buddhist, or is one who has “tried” God and failed.



The reason? Many don’t believe in God, don’t believe in miracles, and say that they may go to church for their religion but only go to A.A. for their alcoholism. Or someone has never read to them page 57 which states:



Seemingly he could not drink even if he would. God had restored his sanity. What is this but a miracle of healing? Circumstances made him willing to believe. He humbly offered himself to his Maker, then he knew. Even so has God restored us all to our right minds.

     

           Or someone has never challenged them as to whether they believed the statement on page

          15:



There is a solution. . . . The great fact is just this, and nothing less. That we have had had deep and effective spiritual experiences. . . . The central fact of our lives today is the absolute certainty that our Creator has entered into our hearts and lives in a way which is indeed miraculous. He has commenced to accomplish those things for us which we could never do by ourselves.



Or the howlers have been led to believe they cannot read, quote, or believe any literature          that is not “Conference-approved.” Therefore they may never have read the account of how Clarence Snyder, founder of Cleveland A.A., was healed of his alcoholism. In Mitchell K.’s How It Worked: The Story of Clarence H. Snyder and the Early Days of Alcoholics Anonymous in Cleveland, Ohio, page 70 states this:



At Clarence’s surrender, T. Henry, Doc, and a couple of the other Oxford Group members went into T. Henry’s bedroom. They all, including Clarence, who by now was used to this kneeling, got down on their knees in an attitude of prayer. They all placed their hands on Clarence, and then proceeded to pray.



These people introduced Clarence to Jesus as his Lord and Savior. They explained to Clarence that this was First Century Christianity. Then they prayed for a healing and removal of Clarence’s sins, especially his alcoholism. When he arose, said Clarence, he once again felt like a new man.

     

The details about these “real surrenders,” in which a newcomer was led to accept Jesus Christ as his Lord and Savior and in which he and others prayed for his healing are not confined to Clarence Snyder—though they have independently been confirmed by many. (See Dick B., That Amazing Grace: The Role of Clarence and Grace S. in Alcoholics Anonymous, 27; and Three Clarence Snyder Sponsee Old-timers and Their Wives, Compiled and Edited by Dick B., Our A.A. Legacy to the Faith Community: A Twelve-Step Guide for Those Who Want to Believe, 20-28.)



The requirement that all early A.A. newcomers profess a belief in God and accept Jesus Christ as Lord and Savior was personally confirmed by me in telephone conversations with A.A. old-timer Ed Andy of Lorain, Ohio, and by Larry B., an A.A. old-timer from Cleveland, Ohio. In addition, I still have in my possession Larry’s letter to me stating the facts and that they had taken him upstairs and had him become “a born-again human being” and “God’s helper to alcoholics.” And the biographer of Dr. William D. Silkworth quoted Dr. Silkworth to the same effect: Bill W. had originally insisted on surrenders to God and coming to Him through His Son Jesus Christ—just as Bill W. had done at Calvary Mission in 1934. (See Dick B., The Conversion of Bill W.: More on the Creator’s Role in Early A.A., 50-76.)



All three of the first AAs—Bill W., Dr. Bob, and A.A. Number Three, who were all Christians and had studied the Bible—stated in writing that they had been cured.



·         [Bill W. said to the wife of A.A. Number Three, Bill D.] “Henrietta, the Lord has been so wonderful to me, curing me of this terrible disease, that I just want to keep talking about it and telling people.” [Alcoholics Anonymous, 4th ed., 191]

·         [Dr. Bob said of Bill W.:] “. . . [T]his was a man who had experienced many years of frightful drinking, . . . but who had been cured . . .” [Alcoholics Anonymous, 4th ed., 180]

·         [A.A. Number Three, Bill D., said:] “That sentence, ‘The Lord has been so wonderful to me, curing me of this terrible disease, that I just want to keep telling people about it,’ has been a sort of a golden text for the A.A. program and for me.” [Alcoholics Anonymous, 4th ed., 191]

·         [Bill W. said:] “Straightway, Bob called Akron’s City Hospital and asked for the nurse on the receiving ward. He explained that he and a man from New York had a cure for alcoholism. [Alcoholics Anonymous, 4th ed., 188]

·         [Bill W. said:] “So if there was a great Physician who could cure the alcoholic sickness, I had better seek Him now, at once. I had better find what my friend [Ebby T.] had found.” [Alcoholics Anonymous Comes of Age, 61]. Bill seems to have been referring here to the advice that Dr. William D. Silkworth had given Bill on his third visit to Towns Hospital in September 1934. At that time, Dr. Silkworth had told Bill that the “Great Physician,” Jesus Christ, could cure him of his alcoholism. [See Dick B., The Conversion of Bill W., 52-53, 58-63, 66-71].



In addition to the declarations by the first three AAs that they had been cured; and the advice Dr. Silkworth gave to Bill—that Jesus Christ, the “Great Physician” could cure him of his alcoholism—many others declared in person and often in newspaper interviews, columns, and articles across the nation that they had been cured. The General Service Office (GSO) of A.A. in New York City has sold—and may still be selling—a scrap book for $75.00 that contains Xerox copies of newspaper interviews from around the United States (done over a 10-year period from about 1939 to 1949) in which alcoholics declared that they had been cured. (See Dick B., Cured!: Proven Help for Alcoholics and Addicts, 2d ed., 1-5, 9-12, 15-19, 23-24, 31-32, 56, 85, 98, 104-06, 125-31.)



Those alcoholics whose personal stories were published in the Big Book first edition told exactly the procedure they followed after A.A. was founded in June 1935 and after the first group was founded only a few days later, on July 4, 1935. The cures, as to which they attested and which they claimed, are numerous. See Dick B., When Early AAs Were Cured and Why, 3rd ed., 107-19, 143-62, 1-8, 20-21, 33-35.



Gloria Deo

Thursday, August 16, 2012

The James Club and the Original A.A. Program's Absolute Essentials

James Club and
The Original A.A. Program’s Absolute Essentials

The James Club and the Original A.A. Program's Absolute Essentials by Dick B. For years, A.A. has quietly acknowledged, primarily through one publication, that the early A.A. pioneers in Akron believed firmly that the answer to all their problems was in the Good Book, as they called the Bible. A.A. co-founder Dr. Bob said that all the basic ideas were taken from their study of the Good Book. And he added many many times that the three parts of the Bible the old timers considered “absolutely essential” to their spiritual program of recovery were: (1) The Book of James. (2) Jesus’s Sermon on the Mount, found in Matthew Chapters 5, 6, and 7. (3) 1 Corinthians 13, Paul’s famous chapter on “love.”
You can find the foregoing remarks in A.A.’s DR. BOB and the Good Oldtimers, in pamphlets published by Akron AA, and in several talks given through the years by Dr. Bob himself. And it was even his co-founder friend Bill Wilson who spoke of the studies of James, the Sermon, and Corinthians; the reading of these passages by Dr. Bob’s wife Anne to Bill and Bob; and the fact that—as Bill put it—“James was our favorite.” And he added that many favored calling the A.A. fellowship “The James Club.”
All this and much much more is detailed in Dick B.’s 25th published title on the Biblical roots of Alcoholics Anonymous. But this title offers a great deal more. In three major parts, it provides a detailed framework for studying each of the three Bible parts—just as the A.A. pioneers did. The reader can sit with his Bible open beside him, his Big Book available for reference, and Dick’s The James Club title before him. He, the newcomer, and others individually or as a group can study each of the three parts, digest their messages, compare with the A.A. program and its ideas, and then apply these biblical truths in daily life, in practicing the Twelve Steps, and in understanding the miracles that the Creator Yahweh wrought when the pioneers read and believed!
Each of the three parts carries a special message, though all three fit together. Bill W. and Dr. Bob both said that the Sermon on the Mount contained the underlying philosophy of A.A.—perhaps embodying the Golden Rule (“do unto others as you would have them do unto you”). And Dick’s title explores just how each verse in Matthew illustrates the way in which Jesus said his followers were to “do the will” of his father which is in heaven. You’ll see the many parts of the Sermon that were adopted into the A.A. Steps and Big Book language and ideas.
The title begins with the Book of James, however. Dick details why it has primacy in the study—based in part on its being the AAs’ favorite and in part on the ease with which it can be read and understood. Yet the meat of this wonderful book lies in its explicit formula for cure—especially the cure of the alcoholic. James speaks of patience. He speaks of enduring temptation. He speaks of seeking God’s wisdom without doubting. He speaks of temptation as the enticement which turns into sin and finally death. He strongly suggests that the readers be “doers of the word (the Bible) not hearers only, deceiving themselves. He spells out what “doing” the Word is. It’s about action; it’s about following the “royal law” of loving thy neighbor; its about benevolent giving without respect of persons and with specific aim at the downtrodden; it’s about backing up one’s “faith” with deeds—“works” as James called them; it’s about guarding the tongue and guarding the thoughts and guarding the actions so that devilish thoughts and impulses do not take over; and finally it’s about the importance of prayer, confession of faults and the Lord’s forgiveness, and about prayer for healings. In a nutshell, this book summarizes the whole pioneer approach in Akron; and, of course, it has nothing to do with “steps” or a “basic text” or the “Oxford Group.” It’s about God’s healing ministry, as A.A. old-timer Clarence Snyder put it.
Then there’s the Thirteenth Chapter of First Corinthians. Its relationship to Henry Drummond’s famous treatise and best-selling book The Greatest Thing in the World is made clear to you. It lays out the nine ingredients (as Drummond called them) of love, and illustrates that one can have the power (spoken of in the preceding 12th chapter) and the application (spoken of in the following 14th chapter) and still have nothing—if not accompanied by the love of God in the renewed mind in manifestation. It concludes that there are faith, hope, and love; but the greatest of these is love.”
You’ll wind up, as Dr. Bob did after 10 years of sobriety, believing that the fundamentals (as he called them) in these three segments will heal you, enlighten you, change you, and make your life the kind of life—the abundant life—that Jesus came to teach about and make available.
To sum up, there are five valuable appendices. The first gives you explicit details on the early A.A. program in Akron. The second explains its roots in United Christian Endeavor and just what the almost-forgotten Christian Endeavor movement taught Dr. Bob and enabled him to bring to the table. The essence was, in Christian Endeavor, as it was seen by Dr. Bob himself. Love and Service. The third appendix explains the vital difference between the Akron program, its founder, and its roots, and the program fashioned four years later by Bill in his Big Book. The fourth dives into the Book of James—its history, its canonical standing, and its author; for James was held, by most, to be the brother of Jesus and the author of the book. The final appendix illustrates how important it is to look to the Bible itself for information about God, Yahweh our Creator. Such information readily builds the readers’ believing and expunges the idea that the false gods in today’s recovery talk have anything to offer but the wrath of God Himself.
Paradise Research Publications, Inc., 224 pp., 6 x 9; perfect bound; 2006; $23.95; ISBN 1-885803-99-0

Wednesday, August 15, 2012

What an AA Member Reads is His Own Business

A formal statement concerning the Conference, the G.S.O, and what AA members read was issued by the General Services Office of AA in 1978.
“WHAT CONFERENCED-APPROVED MEANS”
GSO Box 4-5-9 1978
(Volume 23, No 4)
AA’s General Service Office said:
“It does not mean the Conference disapproves of any other publications. Many local A.A. central offices publish their own meeting lists. A.A. as a whole does not oppose these, any more than A.A. disapproves of the Bible or any other publications from any source that A.A.’s find useful.
What any A.A. member reads is no business of G.S.O., or of the Conference, naturally.”

A.A. Spiritual Experiences, Awakenings, Personality Changes, Awareness


Spiritual Experience, Spiritual Awakening, Personality Change, Awareness



Excerpts Prepared by Ken B. for Our “Conference-approved” Appendix



Occurrences of the Phrase “Spiritual Experience(s)” in the Fourth Edition of Alcoholics Anonymous



The phrase “spiritual awakening” did not occur in the first printing of the first edition of Alcoholics Anonymous (which had a copyright date of April 10, 1939). Even in the fourth edition of Alcoholics Anonymous (2001), the phrase “spiritual awakening” only occurs once up to page 164, and that is on page 60, where the phrase is included in the wording of Step 12: “Having had a spiritual awakening as the result of these steps, . . .” Step 12 originally read, in the first printing of the first edition of Alcoholics Anonymous, “Having had a spiritual experience as the result of these steps, . . .” Here are the occurrences of the phrase “spiritual experience(s)” up through page 164 of the fourth edition and in “Appendix II: Spiritual Experience.”



P. XVI (“Foreword to Second Edition”):      Six months earlier, the broker had been relieved of his drink obsession by a sudden spiritual experience, following a meeting with an alcoholic friend who had been in contact with the Oxford Groups of that day.



            [This Foreword was not included in the first edition. The second edition of Alcoholics Anonymous was first printed in 1955.]





P. 25 (“There Is A Solution”):            The great fact is just this, and nothing less: That we have had deep and effective spiritual experiences(*) which have revolutionized our whole attitude toward life, toward our fellows and toward God's universe.



P. 27 (“There Is A Solution”):            This hope, however, was destroyed by the doctor's telling him that while his religious convictions were very good, in his case they did not spell the necessary vital spiritual experience.



P. 27 (“There Is A Solution”):            Here and there, once in a while, alcoholics have had what are called vital spiritual experiences.



P. 29 (“There Is A Solution”):            Surprisingly enough, we find such convictions no great obstacle to a spiritual experience.



P. 44 (“We Agnostics”):         If that be the case, you may be suffering from an illness which only a spiritual experience will conquer.



P. 47 [“We Agnostics” (Note)]                       (*) Please be sure to read Appendix II on "Spiritual Experience."

                       

[This footnote was not in the first printing of the first edition. It      was added in a later printing of the first edition.]



P. 56 (“We Agnostics”):         One night, when confined in a hospital, he was approached by an alcoholic who had known a spiritual experience.



[** P. 60 (“How It Works”) **]         [Step 12 in the fourth edition reads: “Having had a spiritual awakening as the result of these steps, . . .” Step 12 in the first edition (1939), found on page 72, read: “Having had a spiritual experience as the result of these steps, . . .” The phrase “spiritual experience” was changed to “spiritual awakening” in the second printing of the first edition. “Appendix II: Spiritual Experience” and footnotes on pages 35, 38, and 72 stating “see Appendix II” were also added in the second printing of the first edition. A footnote on page 59 stating “Please See Appendix II” was added in the fourth printing of the first edition. Source: “Big Book Changes”: http://silkworth.net/bb_changes/BB-Changes-02.pdf ; accessed 8/14/12]



P. 66 (“How It Works”):         But with the alcoholic, whose hope is the maintenance and growth of a spiritual experience, this business of resentment is infinitely grave.



P. 75 (“Into Action”): We may have had certain spiritual beliefs, but now we begin to have a spiritual experience.



P. 79 (“Into Action”): Reminding ourselves that we have decided to go to any lengths to find a spiritual experience, we ask that we be given strength and direction to do the right thing, no matter what the personal consequences may be.



P. 119 (“To Wives”):   Your husband will be the first to say it was your devotion and care which brought him to the point where he could have a spiritual experience.



P. 124 (“The Family Afterward”):      In the first flush of spiritual experience they forgave each other and drew closer together.



P. 128 (“The Family Afterward”):      Assume on the other hand that father has, at the outset, a stirring spiritual experience.



P. 130 (“The Family Afterward”):      We have found nothing incompatible between a powerful spiritual experience and a life of sane and happy usefulness.



P. 131 (“The Family Afterward”):      Being possessed of a spiritual experience, the alcoholic will find he has much in common with these people, though he may differ with them on many matters.



P. 155 (“A Vision for You”):  A spiritual experience, he conceded, was absolutely necessary, but the price seemed high upon the basis suggested.



P. 157 (“A Vision for You”):  The two friends spoke of their spiritual experience and told him about the course of action they carried out.



P. 158 (“A Vision for You”):  He had begun to have a spiritual experience.





P. 567 [(569), Appendix II]:   The terms "spiritual experience" and "spiritual awakening" are used many times in this book which, upon careful reading, shows that the personality change sufficient to bring about recovery from alcoholism has manifested itself among us in many different forms.



            [The facts: (a) The phrase “spiritual awakening” did not occur in the first printing of the first edition. (b) The phrase “spiritual awakening” first appeared in the Big Book in the second printing of the first edition, when the phrase “spiritual awakening” was substituted for “spiritual experience” in Step 12, and “Appendix II: Spiritual Experience” (with its two occurrences of the phrase) was added.]



P. 568 [(570), Appendix II):   Most of us think this awareness of a Power greater than ourselves is the essence of spiritual experience.



            [As stated above, “Appendix II: Spiritual Experience” was added to Alcoholics Anonymous in the second printing of the first edition.]

The Important Early AA Personal Stories Freed From "Non-Conference-Approved" Shackles



That Frequently Mentions the Bible and God

(Yep! You Read That Correctly!)



A Four-Part Discussion of the Long-Overlooked Big Book Personal Stories



Part One



Experience, Strength and Hope:

Stories from the First Three Editions of Alcoholics Anonymous

(New York, NY: Alcoholics Anonymous World, Inc., 2003)




By Dick B.

© 2012 Anonymous. All rights reserved







Protests by the Hundreds and Hundreds



“You can’t talk about Jesus or the Bible in A.A. meetings!” “You can’t read from The Good Book and the Big Book: A.A.’s Roots in the Bible by Dick B. here!” “You can’t put Alcoholics Anonymous: The Original 1939 Edition with an Introduction by Dick B. (Dover Publications, 2011) on the table in this meeting!” “You can’t read or sell here Stick with the Winners! How to Conduct More Effective 12-Step Meetings Using Conference-Approved Literature by Dick B. and Ken B. (2012) because it’s not ‘Conference-approved!’” “Furthermore, it’s a ‘violation’ of the Twelve Traditions!”



For many years in meetings, this or that AA has winced and sometimes shouted reproof when someone mentioned the Bible, talked about Jesus Christ, or read from some literature that early AAs read. Sometimes it was about verses from the Bible. That happened to me when I read from the Book of James to an audience of at least 800 AAs at a meeting in which Dr. Bob’s son, the principal author of ‘Pass It On,’ and an Oxford Grouper were also speakers. Nobody left the meeting. But secretive, indirect phone calls from my grand-sponsor and sponsor started arriving as soon as that conference was over. Secretive, but clearly intended to intimidate. However, they failed.



Then there was the claim that anything in A.A. before Alcoholics Anonymous (the Big Book) was published on April 10, 1939, was not really A.A. Also the claim that the original Akron A.A. “Christian fellowship” founded by Bill W. and Dr. Bob in 1935 was “pre-A.A.” You can still find that distortion floating around on websites today. And, since the first edition of the Big Book had not been copyrighted properly by the A.A. hierarchy, it too fell under the condemnation of being “not ‘Conference-approved.’” So for many years the view had been heard and passed along that, if Bill W. hadn’t said it and copyrighted it and received royalties from it, it somehow should not be touched, used, or approved in an A.A. meeting.



This attempted suppression—the early A.A. program blackout—was often excused by calling the early A.A. practices and principles the “flying blind” period or the “trial and error” period. Or through the use of other denigrating labels even though the practices were launched and used by A.A.’s cofounders, Bill W. and Dr. Bob, themselves. And sadly, labels like “flying blind” and similar phrases can still be found in A.A. General Service Conference-approved literature today.



Finally!



As I began my research into the biblical origins of Alcoholics Anonymous shortly before A.A.’s International Convention in Seattle in 1990, and began to publish my work beginning in 1991, the shackles began to fall. The doors began to open. Particularly with the publication of my title The Good Book and the Big Book: A.A.’s Roots in the Bible. Then other literature began to appear—much of it not published by Alcoholics Anonymous World Services, Inc. Finally A.A. itself stepped in with its publication of Experience, Strength and Hope: Stories from the First Three Editions of Alcoholics Anonymous (New York, NY: Alcoholics Anonymous World Services, Inc., 2003). And the copyright page states: “This is A.A. General Service Conference-approved literature.”



There were caveats—warnings—in the introductory portions of Experience, Strength and Hope. But pages ix-x did say:



The importance of these personal stories cannot be overstated. Co-founder Bill W. articulated it in a 1954 letter: “The story section of the Big Book is far more important than most of us think. . . . [I]t is the written equivalent of hearing speakers at an A.A. meeting; it is our show window of results. . . . Thus in the pages that follow, you will meet a large number and variety of A.A.’s from earlier times, whose stories are no longer part of our basic text, but are most emphatically part of our common experience.



However!



Page xi said,



As a collection, therefore, they greatly enrich our knowledge of “what we used to be like” as a Fellowship. Most of the A.A. writers got sober before the Twelve Traditions had been adopted, many of them in that chaotic period when A.A. was flying blind and learning from its many mistakes. (emphasis added)



Do you, as an intelligent reader, think the personal stories in the first edition were merely a “collection” of writings from bygone days in a period when early AAs nonetheless called themselves a “Christian fellowship;” were likened to First Century Christianity; were—for much of the time before Alcoholics Anonymous was published in April 1939—part of “A First Century Christian Fellowship” (also known as “The Oxford Group”); were studying the Bible daily; were having old-fashioned prayer meetings daily; were observing Quiet Time daily; were using Christian devotionals daily; were reading Christian literature daily; were witnessing daily; and were insisting that newcomers believe in God and come to Him through His Son Jesus Christ by accepting Jesus as their Lord and Savior?



If so, then how does a reader explain the fact that the fourth edition of the Big Book states on page 29:



Each individual, in the personal stories, describes in his own language and from his own point of view the way he established his relationship with God.



Was that just an antiquated explanation or a collection of “flying blind” or “trial and error” thoughts about “[t]he central fact of our lives today,” which was “that our Creator has entered into our hearts and lives in a way which is indeed miraculous.” (fourth edition, p. 25). Were that the case, both the book and the stories would be useless. Not!



Was this just what “we used to be like?”



Did the Twelve Traditions somehow trump or supersede God, His Son Jesus Christ, the Bible, prayer, and Quiet Time?



Were the daily Akron fellowship meetings in Dr. Bob’s home and other homes, and those at T. Henry‘s Wednesday night meetings nothing more than pointlessly “chaotic?”



Did the sober teachers of AAs individually and at the meetings—e.g., Anne Ripley Smith, Henrietta Buckler Seiberling, T. Henry Williams, Clarace Williams, Rev. Samuel M. Shoemaker, Jr., Rev. W. Irving Harris, and Dr. Frank N.D. Buchman—merely “fly blind” and make “many mistakes?”



That’s not how Bill Wilson explained the God-given results surveyed in November 1937. In an article written as a memorial tribute to Dr. Bob in January 1951, and published in The Language of the Heart, Bill is quoted at page 359 as follows:



In that fall of 1937 Bob and I counted forty cases who had significant dry time—maybe forty years for the whole lot of them! Our eyes glistened. Enough time had elapsed on enough cases to spell out something quite new, perhaps something great indeed. Suddenly the ceiling went up. We no longer flew blind. A beacon had been lighted. God had shown alcoholics how it might be passed from hand to hand. Never shall I forget that great and humbling hour of realization shared with Dr. Bob. (emphasis added).



Later, in Alcoholics Comes of Age, age page 26, Bill discussed the same event and illustrated to Whom thanks were given for the successes. Bill wrote:



There had been failures galore, but now we could see some startling successes too. A hard core of very grim, last gasp cases had by then been sober a couple of years, an unheard of development. There twenty or more such people. All told we figured that upwards of forty alcoholics were staying bone dry. As we carefully rechecked this score, it suddenly burst upon us that a new light was shining into the dark world of the alcoholic. . . . What a tremendous realization that was. At last we were sure. There would be no more flying totally blind. We actually wept for joy, and Bob and Anne and I bowed our heads in silent thanks. (emphasis added).



Were Bill and Bob and Bob’s wife Anne bowing their heads in thanks for mistakes, for errors, for blindness? No! Was it a humbling time because of their alleged blindness or were they humbly attributing the success to God and His guidance!



A few verses from the Book of James—the favorite of all three (Bill, Bob, and Anne)—suggest quite clearly the reason for the humility and the thanks to God for deliverance. They were attributing the light, the guidance, and the victory to God! The verses say:



Submit yourselves therefore to God. Resist the devil, and he will flee from you.

Draw nigh to God, and he will draw nigh to you. . . .

Humble yourselves in the sight of the Lord, and he shall lift you up. (Jam 4:7, 8, 10)



Do you really believe that, collectively, the teachers and students who were at it daily--reading the Bible, praying, and asking God for guidance--were frittering away their hard service to God and to others in a riotous “chaotic” program of far less importance and value than the often vulgar, “relationship-questing,” and mindless chatter of uninstructed, diverse “meeting makers” today?



Or are drunks, drunks? Were drunks, drunks? Are addicts, addicts? Were addicts, addicts? Were and are they just suffering people who have acknowledged their unmanageable lives and cannot help themselves or be helped by other human beings? Were they merely sick people blindly trying this and that as God watched them fail even as they sought Him and believed He could and would help? No they weren’t! All were Christians with a knowledge of God’s Word who thoroughly followed a path of prayer, Bible study, Quiet time, and service. And the ones who thoroughly followed that path “rarely failed.”



What do the first, the second, the third, or the fourth editions of Alcoholics Anonymous tell us. They show—particularly the personal stories of the first edition—that he who turns to God for help, who prays effectively as a righteous person, and who endeavors to learn and obey God’s will as laid out in the Bible is someone who rarely will fail. Human “mistakes” and the shortcomings of the afflicted can scarcely be compared in effectiveness with the truth of the Bible that early AAs studied daily and which “made” them free!



Yet the Opinions Continued



Page 2 of Experience, Strength and Hope says:



The stories that follow, reprinted from the first edition, take us back to the “trial and error” days, . . . They were still a little unsure and afraid of this “thing” they had found  [God is not a “thing” to be “found.” He is the creator of the heavens and the earth who is to be sought and obeyed], still groping for clear guidelines, still largely “uneducated about their alcoholism.” (emphasis added)



[Note the “trial and error,” “thing,” “groping,” “guidelines,” and “uneducated” words. These, while the subsequently-published Big Book spoke—not of trial and error, not of finding a “thing”—but of finding God. The Big Book did not use such mischaracterizing words as “groping,” unclear “guidelines,” and “uneducated.” The first edition personal stories were not talking about uneducated groping or fuzzy “guidelines.” They talked of a program where guidance was sought directly from God and also from His Word, the Bible.]



Much of the terminology is strange to us: they wrote of “former alcoholics,” described their recovery as a “cure,” and referred to alcohol in such terms as “John Barleycorn.”



[Once again, the language of the Big Book itself, on page 191 of its latest edition, still carries the statement of A.A. cofounder Bill Wilson himself (reiterated and commented upon by “A.A. Number Three,” Bill D.):



“Henrietta, the Lord has been so wonderful to me, curing me of this terrible disease, that I just want to keep talking about it and telling people.”



And did not that “cure”—so plainly and simply described—truly make all three of the first alcoholics “former alcoholics?”]



Just the Facts, Please!



Page 3 of Experience, Strength and Hope recants slightly. It says:



. . . [T]he differences between the stories we hear today and those written in 1939 are not important. These writers were alcoholics, and their experience rings true to any A.A. member of any time or place.



Who, among the Pioneers, Was Doing the Investigating, Teaching, and Writing?



Dr. Bob and Bill W.’s Many Mentors Deserve the First Mention



Dr. Bob was teacher, learner, and leader! He had graduated from St. Johnsbury Academy; graduated from Dartmouth; and attended the following medical schools—University of Michigan; Rush Medical College; Mayo Clinic in Rochester, Minnesota; and Jefferson Medical School in Philadelphia> He had also been awarded a highly coveted internship at City Hospital in Akron. Moreover, he was thoroughly trained in the Bible by his father, a judge and Academy examiner; by his mother, a state library commissioner, Academy teacher, and writer; by YMCA workers and Academy teachers; and by Congregational pastors, teachers, and deacons. He was hardly an “uneducated” groper!



Dr. Bob was educated in his Christian home, church, Sunday school, and prayer meetings. He was active in the very demanding and serious Young People’s Society of Christian Endeavor. He attended the required daily chapel at St. Johnsbury Academy with its sermons, prayers, hymns, and Scripture reading. He also attended the required weekly Bible studies and church services while in St. Johnsbury Academy.



Dr. Bob said plainly and boldly in his last major talk quoted in the A.A. General Service Conference-approved pamphlet, The Co-Founders of Alcoholics Anonymous (P-53):



I had refreshed my memory of the Good Book, and I had had excellent training in that as a youngster. (pp. 11-12)



And his ready and constant references to the Bible in early A.A. bespeak that training—something that Bill W. applauded more than once. And then, in preparation for sobriety sought first with Oxford Group friends, he read the Bible from cover to cover three times. (See DR. BOB and the Good Oldtimers, 310.) He also made of a habit of reading a wide variety of books. He estimated that he had read on average an hour a day for many years.



Anne Ripley Smith, Bob’s wife, was a graduate of Wellesley and had been a teacher.



Henrietta Buckler Seiberling was a graduate of Vassar, and was an avid Bible student and reader.



T. Henry Williams was a brilliant and successful inventor, and a former Sunday school teacher.



Clarace Williams had extensive Baptist training to prepare her to be a missionary.



Dr. William D. Silkworth was considered the leading authority on alcoholism in the United States at that time.



The long-dead Professor William James and the Swiss psychiatrist Dr. Carl Jung were considered tops in the areas where their work and studies had contributed ideas.



Rev. Samuel M. Shoemaker, Jr., was a graduate of Princeton; a YMCA leader; and an author of more than 30 books, and countless articles and sermons. He also held many prestigious positions in the Episcopal Church.



Frank Amos, who investigated the Akron program for the Rockefeller group, was hardly “flying blind” when he visited Akron, spent several days interviewing participants in and observers of the Akron “Christian fellowship,” specifically summarized their program in seven points, and specifically described their successes. And the Rockefeller people—top executives and religious leaders--who met with the early AAs were elated to find that theirs was “First Century Christianity at work.” All the Rockefellers were devoted Christian readers and spokespeople—not just “uneducated,” “trial and error” bystanders.



Bill Wilson Himself



Somehow, in 2003--with Bill W., Dr. Bob, and most if not all of the other early AAs, dead and gone—the writer(s) of the A.A. General Service Conference-approved publication Experience, Strength and Hope felt it appropriate to assert on page two that A.A.’s cofounders and other early pioneers



were still a little unsure and afraid of this “thing” they had found, still groping for clear guidelines, still largely uneducated about their alcoholism.



In a sense, the Johnny-come-lately editors in 2003 were rejecting and disparaging the very education and religious training that had characterized the leadership of Bill Wilson, and of Dr. Bob before him.



Bill W. was trained in East Dorset, Vermont, by his well-educated and successful paternal grandfather Fayette Griffith; and by the pastor and people at East Dorset Congregational Church. In Manchester, Vermont, he was trained by the ministers, teachers, and lay Congregationalists at Burr and Burton Seminary. In Northfield, Vermont, he was trained by a similar group at Norwich Military Academy. And in New York, he was trained by his Oxford Group friends—Ebby Thacher, Rowland Hazard, Shep Cornell, and Cebra Graves, all of whom had Christian upbringings and/or training.



Bill’s writing capability and written words alone marked him as a man who was hardly “flying blind,” tinkering with “trial and error” methods, and “uneducated” as to the medical and religious aspects of the program that he heard and learned about frequently from his friends and mentors, Dr. William D. Silkworth, Rev. Samuel M. Shoemaker, Jr., Rev. W. Irving Harris, Dr. Frank Buchman, and Dr. Norman Vincent Peale.



The Explanatory First Edition Tool Just Published by Dover Publications



Shortly, we will review the specifics of the first edition of Alcoholics Anonymous. We will discuss how the personal stories in the first edition actually explain the original Akron “Christian fellowship” program, and boldly talk of God, His Son Jesus Christ, and the Bible. Ironically, because there was not a Big Book and were no Twelve Steps until Alcoholics Anonymous was published in April 1939, the writers of the personal stories were not even talking about the program Bill had just extracted largely from Rev. Sam Shoemaker and embodied in the language that preceded the personal stories.



More important, perhaps, in Part Two of this four-part series of articles, we will review the purpose, contents, and conclusions found in the Introduction to the recently-published book by Dover Publications: Alcoholics Anonymous:  The Original 1939 Edition, with a new Introduction by Dick B. (Mineola, NY: Dover Publications, 2011).



Gloria Deo






Have You Read The Virtually Lost Big Book 1st Ed. Personal Stories!


A.A. General Service Conference-Approved Literature

That Frequently Mentions the Bible and God

(Yep! You Read That Correctly!)



A Four-Part Discussion of the Long-Overlooked Big Book Personal Stories



Part Two



Alcoholics Anonymous: The Original 1939 Edition

(Dover Publications, Inc., 2011)




By Dick B.

© 2012 Anonymous. All rights reserved





About the Prior Part One



In Part One, we discussed the A.A. General Service Conference-approved book, Experience, Strength and Hope: Stories from the First Three Editions of Alcoholics Anonymous (New York, NY: Alcoholics Anonymous World Services, Inc., 2003). It elevated to “Conference-approved” status the many personal stories from the first edition of the Big Book (1939), the second edition (1955), and the third edition (1976) that were not included in the fourth edition (2001).



For example, of the 29 personal stories in the first edition, 22 were not included in the second edition. (The third edition contained the same seven stories from the first edition that were included in the second edition.) Four more of the stories from the first edition were not included in the fourth edition. This left only three of the original 29 stories from the first edition still present in the fourth edition: (1) “Dr. Bob’s Nightmare,” the personal story of A.A. cofounder Dr. Bob; (2) “Our Southern Friend,” which was substantially rewritten for the second edition; and (3) “The Fearful One,” which was retitled “The Man Who Mastered Fear” and substantially rewritten for the second edition.



We pointed to the questionable explanations in Experience, Strength and Hope for the omission of so many of the first edition’s personal stories from later editions of Alcoholics Anonymous. For example:



·         “As a collection, . . . they [the personal stories included in the first, second, and/or third editions that were omitted from the fourth edition] greatly enrich our knowledge of ‘what we used to be like’ as a Fellowship.” (p. xi).

·         Many “of the A.A. writers [of the omitted personal stories] got sober . . . in that chaotic period when A.A. was ‘flying blind’ and learning from its many mistakes” (p. xi).

·         The first edition’s personal stories omitted from later editions “. . . take us back to the ‘trial and error’ days, . . .” (p. 2).

·         “The A.A.s we meet here . . . [were] still largely uneducated about their alcoholism.” (p. 2).

·         “Some of the rough edges found in the first edition stories (. . . , for example, references to specific religious beliefs, . . .) would be smoothed out in those chosen for later editions.” (pp. 2-3). [emphasis added in quotes above]



About This Part Two:

How the First Edition and Its Personal Stories, Accompanied by the Dick B. Introduction in the Dover Publications Reprint, Can Really Help Drunks Seek and Be Helped by God



Here in Part Two, we propose that those in 12-Step Fellowships freely use today two major tools:



1.      Experience, Strength & Hope (http://goo.gl/ypDmR). Point to, and boldly state, the fact that all of the personal stories included in the first, second, and third editions are now A.A. General Service Conference-approved. And that it is thus entirely appropriate to quote from them as part of carrying the message today to those who still suffer. This can be done by presenting information from and about those stories directly from the new A.A. General Service Conference-approved publication, Experience, Strength and Hope.



2.      Alcoholics Anonymous: The Original 1939 Edition, with a new Introduction by Dick B. (Mineola, NY: Dover Publications, Inc., 2011) [http://goo.gl/OW5TY]. Use for general reading, authoritative facts, and application of “old-school” A.A. principles today, Alcoholics Anonymous: The Original 1939 Edition: With a new Introduction by Dick B. This title will help you use more effectively the first edition’s personal stories that were intended to show how and why the original, “old-school” program—summarized in seven points by Frank Amos in DR.BOB and the Good Oldtimers at page 131—had produced the early successes A.A. claimed (i.e., a 75% success rate overall and a 93% success rate documented in Cleveland). To show how and why those successes were attained by relying on God, accepting His Son Jesus Christ as Lord and Savior, obeying God’s will, using the Bible and prayer, and helping others. Bearing in mind and taking special note that the personal stories did not and could not mention the Big Book or the Twelve Steps because neither existed prior to the publication of Alcoholics Anonymous in April 1939.



What You Will Learn from Alcoholics Anonymous: The Original 1939 Edition (Dover)



·         You will see the facts for yourself as to whether the Big Book language has been changed. (For example, check the wording of Step Twelve in the first printing of the first edition of Alcoholics Anonymous.) And you will see that the entire program based on Bill Wilson’s conversion at Calvary Mission and spiritual experience at Towns Hospital was completely altered when the A.A. solution, a “spiritual experience”—see chapter two in the Big Book (“There Is a Solution”)—was replaced with a “spiritual awakening” and “the personality change sufficient to bring about recovery from alcoholism.” [See “Appendix II: Spiritual Experience,” pp. 567-68, in the fourth edition of Alcoholics Anonymous.]



·         You will see from the original, first edition personal stories just how many times Jesus Christ and Christianity were mentioned, how many times the Bible was mentioned, and how very frequently reliance on God (not some nonsense god or illusory higher power) was stressed.



·         You will see from the extensive Introduction by Dick B. the importance of the first edition personal stories; e.g., the precise places where God, Christianity, and the Bible were mentioned; and how these stories fit so neatly with the real Akron A.A. “Christian fellowship” program that has been the subject of so many Dick B. books and articles. See, for example: The Dick B. Christian Recovery Guide, 3rd ed., 2010.



Part Two: Direct Quotes from Personal Stories

[Using page numbers from Alcoholics Anonymous: The Original 1939 Edition (Dover)]



1.      The first story is Dr. Bob’s. And the last page—193—will suffice:



If you think you are an atheist, an agnostic, a skeptic, or have any other form of intellectual pride which keeps you from accepting what is in this book, I feel sorry for you. . . . Your Heavenly Father will never let you down!



2.      “The Unbeliever,” pp. 194-205:



I asked him desperately what it was. And he said, “God.”



. . . [I]f I will humble myself, if I will give in and bow in submission to that SOMETHING and then try to lead a life as fully in accord with my idea of good as possible, I will be in tune. And later the word good contracted in his mind to God.



God, have mercy on my soul!



3.      “The European Drinker,” pp. 206-16:



You can’t win unless you try God’s way.



. . . [H]e made God seem personal to me, explained Him as a being who was interested in me, the alcoholic, and that all I needed to do was to follow His way; that as long as I followed it I would be able to overcome my desire for liquor.



And he further said that God would not accept me as a sincere follower of His Divine Law unless I was ready to be thoroughly honest about it.



That day I gave my will to God and asked to be directed. . . . So I began to pray; to place my problems in God’s hands.



I have proven to myself and to many others who know me that God can keep a man sober if he will let him.



4.      “A Feminine Victory,” pp. 217-25:



The ability to accept them as my own has been derived from trying with the un-ending help of God. . . .



He asked me if I believed in God. . . . Well, I did believe in God. . . .



“Our Father which art in Heaven.”



I had been taught to realize there is a God and to “love” him.



“Here it is God, all mixed up. I don’t know how to un-mix it, I’ll leave it to you”



Finally I . . . briefly asked God to show me how to do what He wanted me today.



Well, I got the Bible and “Victorious Living” [Victorious Living is a book read widely by early AAs and written by E. Stanley Jones—whose books Dr. Bob’s wife recommended as “all good.”] and sitting down in full view of the bottle of whiskey, I commenced to read. I also prayed.



            I must keep myself worthy of Divine help.



5.      “Our Southern Friend,” pp. 226-41:



Suddenly a thought comes. Can all the worthwhile people I have known be wrong about God?



            “Who are you to say there is no God?” It rings in my head. I can’t get rid of it.



I tumble out of bed onto my knees. I know not what I say. But slowly a great peace comes to me. I feel lifted up. I believe in God. I crawl back into bed and sleep like a child.



Today as I become more harmonized within, I become more in tune with all of God’s wonderful creation. . . . [A]nd a host of other things tell me of the glory of God.



            And with it, direction by the Spirit of God.



And above all else comes a greater thankfulness to, and a greater love for Our Father in heaven.



6.      “A Business Man’s Recovery,” pp. 242-51:



The thing that Bill told me was his own story. . . . I had always believed in God even though I was not a devout church goer.



Crazy as the idea seemed when broached to me by these men who had found it worked, God did come right into my work, when permitted, as He had come into the other activities connected with my life.



7.      “Traveler, Editor, Scholar,” pp. 254-64. A.A. itself wrote: “Originally published under the title ‘Traveler, Editor, Scholar’ in the first edition. The title was changed to ‘The News Hawk’ and the story was edited for the second edition.” (Experience, Strength and Hope, 268) (emphasis added)]



I found my friend was there for alcoholism and now he was insisting that he had found the only cure. I listened to him, rather tolerantly. I noticed a Bible on his table and it amazed me. I had never known him to be anything but a good healthy pagan with a propensity for getting into liquor jams and scrapes.



I had never, since the believing days of childhood, been able to conceive an authority directly the universe. But I had never been a flippant, wise-cracking sneerer at the few persons I had met who had impressed me as Christian men and women. . . . No conviction was necessary to establish my status as a miserable failure at managing my own life. I began to read the Bible daily . . .



I can remember the urge of the Prodigal Son to return to his Father. . . .



. . . in those days I had no one to whom I might take my troubles. Today I have. Today I have Someone who will always hear me . . .